Midway, Utah Home Values Rose 2.7%. The Homes That Actually Sold Went for 5% Less.

I get a version of this question almost every week from people looking at Midway. They pull up a home value site and see the number is up. Then they pull up a different site and see the opposite. So which one is right?

Both of them, actually. They are measuring two different things, and once you understand what each number represents, Midway's market makes a lot more sense, whether you are buying or selling this fall.

Midway Home Prices: What the Two Numbers Actually Say

Zillow's typical home value for Midway sits at $941,303, up 2.7% over the past year, according to Zillow's Midway home values page. That figure is a smoothed estimate across the entire housing stock, not just the homes that changed hands. Zillow also puts Midway's median sale price at $914,667 as of June 30, 2026, against a median list price of $980,333 as of July 31.

Redfin tells a different part of the story. Looking at the three months ending in August 2026, the median price of homes that actually closed in Midway was $1,048,006, down 5.4% from a year earlier, according to Redfin's Midway market data. Only 48 homes sold in that window, down about 9% from the year before.

Put plainly, the overall value of Midway's housing stock is still climbing, but the specific homes that changed hands this summer sold for meaningfully less than a year ago, and fewer of them sold at all. That is not a contradiction. It is what a market looks like when it thins out at the top while holding its value underneath.

Why Midway Homes Are Sitting Longer

Redfin puts Midway's median time on market at 82 days, 11 days longer than a year ago. Zillow's median days to pending, a slightly different measure, sits at 43 days. Either way, the direction is the same: buyers are taking longer to commit. Midway had 134 active listings as of the end of July, with only 32 new listings hitting the market that same month.

Part of that is financing. Freddie Mac's Primary Mortgage Market Survey put the 30-year fixed rate at 6.95% as of September 17, 2026, up from 6.26% a year earlier, according to Freddie Mac. That is roughly 70 basis points of extra financing cost stacked on top of prices that had already climbed for years, which is enough to slow a market without collapsing it. That is exactly what these Midway numbers show.

Sellers are still getting close to their number once they do find a buyer. Redfin has Midway's sale-to-list ratio at 97.1%, actually up eight tenths of a point from a year ago. Homes are taking longer to find a buyer, but the buyers who do show up are not demanding steep discounts once they are under contract.

How Midway Stacks Up Against the Rest of the Heber Valley

Midway sits inside the broader Heber Valley submarket that the Park City Board of REALTORS tracks. In the second quarter of 2026, Heber Valley single family homes recorded 97 sales totaling $147.2 million, a median of $940,000, up 2% in units but down 10% in dollar volume from a year earlier, according to the Park City Board of REALTORS Q2 2026 report. The rolling 12 month median for the valley sits at $1.05 million, up about 1%.

Condos tell a rougher story. Heber Valley condos posted just 12 sales for $7.8 million in the second quarter, down 64% in units and 62% in dollar volume year over year. The Board's report specifically flagged that the Heber North area recorded zero condo sales in the second quarter of 2026, compared to 25 the year before. If you are picturing a condo purchase in this valley right now, know that inventory and buyer interest in that segment has genuinely dried up, not just slowed down.

Midway's Short-Term Rental Numbers, By the Data

A lot of buyers ask me about Midway as an income property before they ask about it as a home. The numbers are real but modest next to its neighbor. According to AirDNA data compiled in a Heber Valley and Midway short-term rental report, Midway listings averaged a $273 nightly rate with 25.2% occupancy and roughly $17,365 in average monthly revenue as of the end of July 2026.

Heber City, just down the road, ran hotter: a $530 average daily rate, 29.8% occupancy, and about $36,374 in average monthly revenue over the same period. The report's own conclusion is worth repeating here: Midway and Heber City are genuinely different rate bands, not one blended Wasatch Back number, and Midway's higher nightly rate relative to its occupancy suggests its inventory skews toward larger, higher-end cabins rather than volume rentals.

What's Pulling Buyers Toward Midway Right Now

The number that actually changes how I talk to buyers about this valley is not a Midway statistic at all. It is the buildout underway a few minutes away at Jordanelle and the new Deer Valley East Village. Planning documents point to more than 6,000 new residential units at full buildout, a mix of roughly 1,267 single family homes, 3,240 townhomes and condos, and about 1,700 hotel and hotel-condo units, according to reporting from TownLift. That project is roughly 22% complete today and is projected to reach about two thirds complete within five years, with full buildout targeted around 2035 to align with the 2034 Winter Olympics, when Deer Valley will serve as a host venue.

Midway does not get a ski lift or an Olympic banner. What it gets is proximity, a genuinely different pace of life, and a lower price of entry than almost anything inside Park City limits. Locals already know Midway for the Homestead Crater's geothermal spring, the Soldier Hollow Nordic center left over from the 2002 Games, the Zermatt resort's Swiss-village feel, and a small but growing cluster of wineries and farms. None of that shows up in a spreadsheet, but it is a real part of why buyers who get priced out of Heber City or Park City keep landing in Midway instead.

Midway Real Estate Questions I Get Every Week

Is Midway, Utah a good place to buy right now?
It depends on your time horizon. Prices on the homes actually closing have softened this summer and days on market have stretched out, which favors patient buyers with room to negotiate. The longer term value trend, and the scale of development happening a few minutes away at Jordanelle, are why I still tell buyers this is not a market to write off.

How does Midway compare to Heber City?
Heber City is larger, has more short-term rental activity, and the broader Heber Valley posted a $940,000 single family median in the Board's Q2 2026 data. Midway is smaller and quieter, and its rental performance skews toward fewer, higher-end properties rather than volume.

Can I run a short-term rental in Midway?
Many properties can, but rules vary by subdivision and by whether you are inside city limits or the surrounding unincorporated area. Verify zoning and HOA rules in writing before you buy with that plan in mind, not after.

Will the Jordanelle and Deer Valley East Village growth affect Midway home values?
It is reasonable to expect it will, given the scale of the project and Midway's proximity, but that buildout runs through roughly 2035. Treat it as a long term tailwind, not a reason to overpay today.

Thinking About Moving to Utah? Let's Talk.

Utah is one of the fastest-growing states in the entire country, and navigating the cultural landscape alongside the real estate market takes genuine local expertise. Whether you're considering Salt Lake County, Utah County, Davis County, or further out — finding the right neighborhood for your lifestyle, budget, and long-term goals makes all the difference.

My team and I work exclusively with buyers and sellers navigating the Utah real estate market. We help you cut through the noise, match the right submarket to your specific lifestyle and priorities, and make sure you're buying from a position of clarity — not FOMO.

Book a call with us HERE — free 30-minute consultation

Check out our relocation guide HERE

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter HERE